BSIMM: Understanding the Building Security In Maturity Model

BSIMM, or Building Security In Maturity Model, is a descriptive model that provides a baseline for observed activities within software security initiatives. It's based on research involving Aetna, HSBC, and Cisco, organizations with diverse methodologies and terminology. Therefore, BSIMM offers a common vocabulary to unite these companies’ varied approaches.

BSIMM studies existing software security initiatives to identify and quantify common practices. But it doesn't stop there—it also highlights unique variations. This way, organizations can see not just what's typical but also what's innovative in software security.

The model does not prescribe a one-size-fits-all solution. Instead, it provides insight into how different organizations handle security, giving you a foundational understanding of the landscape. 

So if you're involved in software security, BSIMM can be a valuable tool that offers an objective view of your current initiative and lets you compare your efforts with those of industry peers, and track your progress over time. 

BSIMM vs SAMM. How do they differ?

BSIMM is strictly descriptive. It doesn't tell you what to do. Instead, it shows you what's happening in the real world. This differs from prescriptive models like the Software Assurance Maturity Model (SAMM). 

SAMM is more about providing a roadmap for you to follow. It's great if you need guidance on moving from one maturity level to another. It gives you steps, kind of like a recipe, for improving your security practices. BSIMM doesn't do that. It focuses on observing and reporting what's already in place across various organizations.

For instance, when a company participates in a BSIMM assessment, the results show how its security practices compare to others. This comparison is based on real data from companies like Aetna, HSBC, and Cisco. 

A unique feature of BSIMM is its use of a uniform framework to describe varied methodologies and terminologies across organizations. This includes domains like Governance and Deployment, across which BSIMM documents specific activities without passing judgment.

In contrast, SAMM might guide a company on how to improve its software development lifecycle security. It’s like having a playbook with different levels to reach. 

BSIMM, however, tells you how common or rare certain practices are, based on its extensive research. This approach makes BSIMM a mirror rather than a map, useful for understanding the landscape rather than prescribing a specific path forward.

Why BSIMM is important in today's digital landscape

Provides a reality check of your cybersecurity posture

BSIMM is not just theory or best guesses. It's based on real-world data from companies like Aetna, HSBC, and Cisco. This makes it especially relevant when we're all concerned about security breaches and cyber threats. 

The sheer volume of data breaches in recent years highlights the need for solid security practices. And this is where BSIMM comes in—it shows us what organizations actually do to secure their software.

Let's say your company is part of the finance industry. You've probably heard about the numerous cyberattacks targeted at financial institutions. With BSIMM, you can see how your security practices stack up against others in your industry. You might even find innovative practices you hadn't considered. This is invaluable as it helps you understand not just what's possible but also what's practical.

A security-focused tour guide

BSIMM doesn't tell you where to go, but it points out the landmarks. For instance, if you're involved in developing healthcare software, BSIMM can reveal common practices specific to that sector. This is crucial as the healthcare industry faces unique regulatory and privacy requirements.

Moreover, as we navigate remote work and digital transformation, the attack surface has grown. Security isn't just about protecting a single office network anymore. It’s about securing countless home offices, cloud applications, and digital interactions. 

BSIMM acknowledges this complexity. By studying various organizations, it reflects a comprehensive view of what's happening across the industry, allowing you to identify gaps and opportunities in your own security initiatives.

Helps you see beyond the walls of your organization

Because it provides a snapshot of the industry's security landscape, BSIMM informs you whether your approaches are typical or outliers. This can be a wake-up call or a pat on the back. Either way, it's an essential part of keeping pace with the fast-evolving digital world.

Core principles of BSIMM

Being descriptive, not prescriptive

It’s like walking through a museum with a map. You’re free to choose where to spend your time. BSIMM doesn’t tell you what to do next. Instead, it reflects what organizations are already doing. 

This isn’t about setting standards or benchmarks. It's more about showing the current reality in software security practices. Imagine being in a room with security experts from companies like Aetna, HSBC, and Cisco. BSIMM captures the essence of those discussions and practices without suggesting changes.

Shared vocabulary

Companies often have unique terms for similar practices, which can be confusing. BSIMM acts like a translator. It provides a common language, making it easier to compare apples to apples. 

For instance, what one company calls "code review," another might label it as "peer review." BSIMM helps bridge that gap by categorizing these practices under a unified framework. This shared language is essential because it allows organizations to understand each other better and learn from one another.

Transparency through real-world data

BSIMM gathers genuine practices observed in the field, not hypothetical models. It's like a weather report showing actual conditions rather than predictions. When you look at BSIMM data, you’re seeing what companies are really doing. This transparency is crucial. It helps you see where your own practices align with industry norms. 

Say you’re in the tech industry and you discover your team is leaning heavily on automated testing. BSIMM might show you that while that's common, manual testing still plays a significant role in other organizations.

Diversity in approach

The BSIMM model doesn't favor one method over another. It respects the myriad ways organizations handle security. If one company has a strong governance policy while another focuses on deployment strategies, BSIMM documents both without judgment. 

This respect for diversity means no single approach is labeled as "best." Instead, you see a spectrum of practices, helping you figure out what fits your context. Dive into BSIMM, and you get a rich tapestry of security activities, reflective of the varied and innovative ways organizations safeguard their software.

Key components and objectives of BSIMM

Structured framework

This framework isn't about setting a path or dictating actions. Instead, it organizes the variety of software security activities observed across different organizations. Imagine this framework as a well-organized library. Each book on the shelf represents a different security practice. 

For example, you'll find books labeled "Configuration Management" or "Code Review." These aren't just random selections. They're based on real practices from companies like Aetna, HSBC, and Cisco.

Assessment

This is the BSIMM assessment itself that acts like a diagnostic tool for software security initiatives. When a company gets assessed, BSIMM measures its activities against a variety of domains and practices. 

Think of this assessment as a health check-up. It doesn't give you a cure but shows you where you stand compared to industry peers. 

Let’s say your organization focuses heavily on threat modeling. The BSIMM assessment might reveal that you're doing well in that area but flag other areas like "Deployment" which might need more attention.

Observational data

This data isn't made up from theory; it's drawn from actual organizational practices. Picture it like a documentary rather than a fiction movie. You're getting an unvarnished look at what’s really happening in software security. 

For instance, if you're working in the financial sector, BSIMM provides insights into common practices in your field. You might learn that "Penetration Testing" is a commonly observed activity among your peers, which could influence your own strategy.

Creating a shared understanding among organizations

BSIMM doesn’t want companies talking past each other. That's why it offers a common language. This language simplifies the complex conversation around software security. 

In practice, this is similar to being part of a global conference call where everyone actually speaks the same language. So, if one organization mentions "risk management," others on the call understand exactly what that entails, thanks to BSIMM's shared vocabulary.

Diversity in security practices

BSIMM doesn’t push for a single best method. Instead, it respects that different approaches work for different organizations. If you're part of a healthcare company, BSIMM might show you a blend of practices like "Privacy Engineering" and "Regulatory Compliance" that fit your needs. This diversity is key because it allows organizations to customize their security practices in ways that work best for them.

The BSIMM framework

The BSIMM framework is a structured way of viewing software security. This framework doesn't set a rigid path for us to follow. Instead, it organizes what different companies, like Aetna and HSBC, are actually doing to protect their software.

The framework is divided into domains, which are broad areas that cover the different aspects of software security. Within these domains are practices, sort of like chapters in a book. These are the specific activities organizations undertake to bolster their software security. 

For instance, in the "Governance" domain, you might find practices related to establishing security policies. In "Deployment," you might learn about activities focused on security in the software release process.

One of the most interesting aspects of BSIMM is its classification of activities into 12 core practices. These core practices cover a wide range, from "Strategy & Metrics," where companies establish their security goals, to "Architecture Analysis," which involves understanding and mitigating architectural risks. 

There's also "Security Testing," which focuses on the nitty-gritty of finding vulnerabilities in the software. Picture these practices as the diverse pieces of a puzzle, each essential to creating a secure software environment.

BSIMM doesn't just list out these practices. It also introduces the idea of maturity levels. This isn't about saying one company is better than another. Instead, it's more about understanding how developed a particular security practice is within an organization. 

Continuous improvement is another cornerstone of the BSIMM framework. In the fast-paced digital world, standing still is not an option. You must keep evolving your security practices. BSIMM encourages you to look at your assessment results and see them as a catalyst for change. 

If, for instance, you're strong in "Vulnerability Management" but see gaps in "Configuration Management," you know where to focus your efforts next. It's like having a roadmap that helps you decide your next move, ensuring that your security practices aren't just reactive but proactive.

This continuous improvement aspect is not just about internal progress. It’s about staying relevant in an ever-evolving industry. By comparing your practices with those highlighted in BSIMM, you get a clearer picture of emerging trends and innovations. 

Implementing BSIMM in Company Networks

Assessment and benchmarking

The first step involves gathering your team and examining what you actually do every day to secure your software. BSIMM is like holding a mirror up to your processes. You aren't trying to meet theoretical ideals; you're looking at your real-world operations.

You start by examining the different domains and practices within the BSIMM framework. It's akin to taking inventory. Suppose you're in the healthcare industry. You might find that BSIMM highlights crucial activities like "Privacy Engineering" and "Regulatory Compliance." You match these against your current practices. If you discover gaps, those become your focus areas for improvement.

Understanding benchmarking results with BSIMM is where things get interesting. After an assessment, you receive detailed feedback. It's like getting a report card, but for your security practices. 

For instance, say you learn that your "Threat Modeling" is on par with your peers but your "Configuration Management" lags behind. This gives you actionable insights. You now know where to buckle down and where you're doing just fine.

Consider a scenario where your company excels in "Security Testing." The benchmarking results confirm you're above the industry average here. That's a pat on the back for your team. 

However, the same assessment might reveal that you need to pay more attention to "Deployment" activities. This doesn't just highlight weaknesses; it informs your strategic planning and budget allocations. You might decide to invest in additional training or tools for your deployment processes.

BSIMM benchmarking also helps you communicate more effectively with stakeholders. It's as if you have a common language grounded in real-world data. When discussing security posture with executives, you can point to the specific areas highlighted by the assessment. This makes it easier to justify investments in certain areas.

One of the benefits of BSIMM benchmarking is that it provides context. It shows you where you stand not just within your own industry but against a wide range of organizations. Imagine learning that a novel practice, like using machine learning for threat detection, is being adopted by leading firms. That's inspiration—and possibly, an innovation you might want to explore.

Through this assessment and benchmarking process, BSIMM acts as your compass. It doesn't dictate where you go, but it does show you the lay of the land. By comparing your practices with the BSIMM framework, you have a clearer picture of what's typical, what's innovative, and where we might carve our niche.

Strategic planning

Strategic planning within the BSIMM framework is all about setting realistic goals and priorities based on what you actually see happening in your organization. You take a close look at your current processes and compare them to the insights from a BSIMM assessment. It's like opening a roadmap before a journey. You need to know where you are before deciding your next destination.

Let's say you've just completed a BSIMM assessment. One of your goals could be to enhance your "Configuration Management" practices because the assessment revealed you're lagging in this area. It's not just about focusing on weaknesses; it's about aligning your priorities with what's achievable and necessary. You might prioritize setting up automated configuration checks, which could also streamline your deployment processes.

In setting these goals, you consider your company's unique context. Suppose you're in the financial industry. A critical priority might be to double down on "Threat Modeling" because of the high stakes involved in protecting sensitive financial data. BSIMM gives you the perspective to see where others in your industry are focusing their efforts, letting you set informed priorities.

BSIMM also helps you spot opportunities for innovation. Maybe your assessment highlighted that you're strong in "Code Review." You might set a strategic goal to leverage this strength by experimenting with new automated tools that enhance code review efficiency. It's not just about catching up to industry standards—it's about leapfrogging over them when you can.

We also use BSIMM to communicate our strategic priorities effectively throughout the organization. For instance, if improving "Security Testing" becomes a top goal, you make sure everyone from developers to executives understands why this matters. You share the specific benchmarking data that led to this decision. This kind of transparency ensures buy-in and aligns everyone around a common purpose.

BSIMM acts as your compass, helping navigate the complex landscape of software security. It nudges you to set goals that are not only ambitious but grounded in reality. Take the example of a healthcare company prioritizing "Privacy Engineering" to comply with regulations. By using the BSIMM framework, strategic planning becomes not just a checklist but a journey towards robust, context-aware security practices.

Aligning BSIMM with business objectives

When you align BSIMM with business objectives, you're essentially bridging the gap between your security practices and your company's overarching goals. 

You begin by examining your business priorities. Maybe you're a healthcare company focused on patient privacy or a financial institution prioritizing data integrity. Whatever your focus, BSIMM provides the insights we need to align your security efforts with these objectives.

For example, if innovation is a key business goal, you might use BSIMM to spot leading-edge security practices you can adopt. Let's say you're intrigued by the idea of using artificial intelligence in security testing. BSIMM helps you see how industry leaders are already doing this, offering a practical way to weave innovation into your security strategy. It's about understanding what's possible and making it happen within your unique context.

Communication is part of this alignment too. You must use the common language BSIMM provides to discuss security objectives with stakeholders. 

Suppose you need to explain the importance of improving your "Configuration Management" to executives. Armed with BSIMM data, you can clearly illustrate how this practice aligns with your company's aim to reduce operational risks. It turns those security initiatives into business conversations, making it easier to prioritize and allocate resources.

BSIMM also becomes a tool for benchmarking. Let's say your company is driven by a goal to be an industry leader. You use BSIMM to measure your security practices against your competitors. If you're lagging in "Threat Modeling," you know where to focus. By improving this area, not only do you bolster your security but also move closer to your business goal of industry leadership.

The beauty of aligning BSIMM with business objectives is its adaptability. It doesn't prescribe a fixed path but offers the flexibility to tailor security practices to meet your business needs. If customer trust is paramount, you might lean heavily on practices that enhance privacy and transparency. BSIMM helps you see what others are doing successfully in this space, providing a practical framework to follow.

Ultimately, it's about making informed decisions that drive both security and business success. By closely aligning your practices with your business objectives, BSIMM acts like your guide, pointing you in the right direction while allowing you to carve a path that truly fits your company’s vision and priorities.

Benefits of BSIMM for company networks

Improved security posture

When you have a clear picture of how you stack up against top organizations like Aetna and Cisco, you're not just guessing or relying on outdated practices. BSIMM gives us real-world insights, which means your security practices are grounded in what's actually working out there. This boosts your confidence. You know your defenses are robust, not because we think so, but because you have data backing you up.

Improved risk management and threat mitigation

With BSIMM, you get a snapshot of where your vulnerabilities lie. It's like having a flashlight in a dark room, showing you exactly where you need to be cautious. 

If you're investing heavily in threat modeling, BSIMM might show you how to tighten your processes further. Or maybe it reveals a blind spot in your deployment practices. Knowing these things helps you preemptively tackle issues before they escalate. You're not just reacting to threats—you're anticipating them.

Enhanced compliance

BSIMM acts as your guide, helping you align with critical regulations whether you're in healthcare, finance, or any other industry with stringent guidelines. 

Say you're a healthcare company; privacy engineering and regulatory compliance are top of your list. BSIMM makes it easier to see how others are meeting these requirements, so you can follow suit. It’s a bit like having a cheat sheet that shows you best practices that are both industry-approved and effective.

Increased stakeholder confidence

When you align your security strategy with BSIMM, you're not just saying you're secure; you're showing it. Stakeholders love that. They want to know their investments are safe. 

If you can present BSIMM benchmarking data that highlights your strong areas—like security testing or code review—it builds trust. Your executives and investors feel more assured, knowing your security posture is aligned with industry leaders.

Stronger trust with clients and partners

This comes naturally when your security practices are top-notch. You can confidently share your commitment to security, backed by BSIMM insights. 

Imagine discussing a partnership and being able to say, "Our security measures are on par with leaders in the field." That’s a powerful statement that signals that you're serious about safeguarding not just your data but theirs as well. Clients feel more secure, and partners see you as a reliable ally in business.

Common BSIMM implementation challenges

Resource allocation and management

It’s a classic case of wanting to do more with less. You might look at your BSIMM assessment and see areas that need improvement, like "Configuration Management." But you quickly realize that addressing these gaps requires time, money, and skilled personnel. 

It’s like planning a vacation without a clear travel budget. You need to know how much you have and how best to use it. If you're stretched thin on experts, you might consider training current staff or even hiring new talent. However, those are decisions not taken lightly, as they impact your operational budget.

Change management and cultural adaptation

Implementing BSIMM isn’t just about ticking off boxes on a checklist. It requires a shift in mindset. Suppose your team isn't used to the rigor of regular "Threat Modeling." Introducing this as a regular practice can feel like asking everyone to run a marathon when they're used to a leisurely stroll. 

Resistance is natural. Some might see it as just more work. So, you tackle this by explaining the why:

• Why does "Threat Modeling" matter? 
• How does it benefit us all? 

You can hold workshops, invite feedback, and celebrate small wins to ease the transition. It's important to show that BSIMM isn’t just a top-down imposition—it’s a collective effort for better security.

Cultural change doesn't happen overnight. Say you're in a company where security wasn't previously front and center. It’s likely you have habits and norms deeply rooted in a different way of working. 

Adopting BSIMM practices means you have to be flexible and patient, both with yourselves and with your colleagues. You might start small, integrating one or two practices at a time. Slowly, you build a culture where security isn’t just an afterthought but an integral part of your DNA.

BSIMM challenges you, but that's not a bad thing. It forces you to get creative with resources and to manage change thoughtfully. By directly addressing these challenges, you can make meaningful strides in strengthening your security posture while also fostering a culture that values continuous improvement and adaptability.

Best practices for successful BSIMM implementation

Start with a clear understanding of your existing security landscape

Gather your team to discuss what you currently do well and where you see potential gaps. This is like taking a baseline snapshot before embarking on a fitness journey. 

For example, if you're already strong in "Threat Modeling," that's your starting point. Build on this strength as you work to address weaker areas like "Configuration Management." This approach ensures you're not overwhelmed and can focus resources effectively.

Prioritize communication and collaboration

You need everyone on board, from executives to developers. It's crucial that you explain the benefits of BSIMM in a way that resonates with each group. When you tell developers how improved security practices can reduce late-stage fixes, they listen. 

For executives, showing how BSIMM aligns with business goals like risk reduction gets their buy-in. You can hold regular meetings or workshops to keep everyone informed and engaged.

Take a phased approach

You don't need to overhaul everything at once. Instead, you can introduce BSIMM practices gradually. You might start with enhancements in "Security Testing" before moving on to "Architecture Analysis." This phased strategy helps you manage resources and change more effectively. It allows your team to adapt to new processes without feeling overwhelmed.

Invest in training to help your team understand the various BSIMM practices

For instance, if "Code Review" is a new focus area, you might bring in experts to conduct workshops. This helps you upskill your staff and ensures everyone has the knowledge they need to succeed. Plus, it fosters a culture of continuous learning, which is vital for adapting to evolving security challenges.

Celebrate small wins

Recognize and reward milestones, no matter how minor they seem. If you successfully implement a new tool for "Code Review", celebrate. These celebrations motivate your team and show that their hard work is paying off. It also helps you maintain momentum and keeps everyone excited about the journey.

Maintain flexibility

While BSIMM provides a framework, understand that one size doesn't fit all. Adapt practices to fit your unique context and industry. If you're in finance, you'll emphasize different aspects than a healthcare company might. You stay flexible, continuously monitoring and adjusting your security practices as you learn more and as your business evolves.

Implementing BSIMM successfully is about understanding your starting point, fostering collaboration, and moving forward in a way that aligns with your unique needs. Keeping these best practices in mind helps you make the journey smoother and more effective.

How Netmaker Enhances Your Software Security Practices

Organizations looking to enhance their software security practices can leverage Netmaker to build robust, secure networks that align with their security goals. Netmaker's ability to create virtual overlay networks using WireGuard technology ensures secure communication between machines across multiple locations, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of software security initiatives. 

By using features like Egress Gateways and Remote Access Clients, companies can manage access to external networks securely and efficiently, facilitating compliance with industry standards and regulations. These capabilities are particularly beneficial in sectors like healthcare and finance, where safeguarding sensitive information is paramount.

Netmaker also supports strategic planning and continuous improvement through its professional metrics feature, which provides insights into connectivity, latency, and data transfer. This data can be visualized in the Netmaker UI or integrated with tools like Grafana for comprehensive analysis. Such insights allow organizations to benchmark their security practices against peers and identify areas for improvement, supporting informed decision-making and resource allocation. 

Furthermore, Netmaker's integration with OAuth providers enhances user management and access control, ensuring only authorized users can access the network. 

Ready to implement Netmaker?

Sign up here to get started with Netmaker and ensure your software security practices align with the latest industry standards.